Personally, i really like it!
I just gave my first In-depth Critique, and i will give a lot more, this is in my opinion just what deviantart needed, seems like more and more people are trying it out.
100+ words is just the right amount to.

--
The states of awareness we currently perceive are only a thiny fraction of the whole.
The continuum extends deep into nonphysical areas of the universe far beyond our current physical comprehension

- William Buhlman

I'm sure it's valuable to some. Personally I'm glad there's a way to shut it off and not have to see them.

--
Be nice to everyone!

I like them, but I'd like to group together them by languages. Sorry for my english ._. Can you correct my sentence?

--
Valentina Blasi Photography


^{I'm sorry, but I cannot reply and thank you all because of the filter which doesn't allow me to post too many messages in a row!}

I like it, but it would be better if every user could post a critique, for they are few people who have the time to write one.

--
Visit my humble gallery!! you might like it! [link]

No comment, since I'm not a subscriber. I will say I don't like that DA removed the critique-preference-for-comments option on deviations - the features aren't mutually exclusive. Even if I can't get formal Critiques, I can still have an opinion about what depth of commentary I'd like...can't I?

I think it is cool that you can critique, but it bugs me that they show up in your message center when someone critiques another's photo.

--
^{Put that in your juice box and suck it!}

I like and I find it quite interesting...
I'd like that my photos were criticized, but now I do not intend to buy a subscription only for critics...

--

OlivierJules.com | facebook | flickr

You write good English, no worries
mhm, that is a good idea actually!

--
The states of awareness we currently perceive are only a thiny fraction of the whole.
The continuum extends deep into nonphysical areas of the universe far beyond our current physical comprehension

- William Buhlman

mhm, it is good to have that option.
you can shut them off from your, or everyones deviations?
Meaning, that you don`t see them when you look at other peoples work that got a critique.

--
The states of awareness we currently perceive are only a thiny fraction of the whole.
The continuum extends deep into nonphysical areas of the universe far beyond our current physical comprehension

- William Buhlman

I guess it is priority.
it only takes a couple of min, but it is not always easy to know what to write, so yes.
But it is a good learning for both parts, so analyze an image, and get one analyzed.

--
The states of awareness we currently perceive are only a thiny fraction of the whole.
The continuum extends deep into nonphysical areas of the universe far beyond our current physical comprehension

- William Buhlman